Holter pickguards?

Well, in theory, the answer is yes. But it's about knowing which pickguard to buy. I'm not all that adept at measuring soundhole radii or things like that, so I wanted to buy from someone who is supposed to know that stuff. That, and his guards are supposed to be better than what's supplied by the factory. Beveled edges, nice torti patterns etc. Might be an attractive enhancement if I decided to ever sell the guitar, and if I don't, it'll look good while I'm playing it.

You are correct. The original pickguard is no longer with me. Part of why I did what I did was because the corner of the pickguard beside the sound hole was starting to peel up on its own without any help from me.

If you were in my shoes, where would you order a replacement from?

The reason I'm asking about whether or not to do business with a Reverb seller off of Reverb is because it reminds me of the one time many years ago when an unscrupulous seller on eBay persuaded me to do business off-site because they wouldn't have to pay the selling fee after the purchase. I got burned in that deal and had no recourse because the "deal" was done off-site. It wasn't a huge loss, but enough to notice and certainly enough to teach a lesson. I'm not saying that this is his intent, but a previous bad experience makes it harder to willingly do business like that again.